Serving McHenry, Lake & Kane County

EXTERIOR TRIM REPAIR AND PAINTING · LAKE IN THE HILLS, IL

Can You Fix Rotten Trim and Paint It Before Winter in Lake in the Hills?

The trim had rotten wood and the season was about to turn. Here's how we replaced the bad spots, caulked and painted it all in one day.

  • Lake in the Hills, IL
  • Completed November 2026
Back of a Lake in the Hills, IL home after we painted the soffit, fascia and wood trim in Sherwin-Williams Latitude stock white

The short answer

This Lake in the Hills, IL homeowner wanted the wood trim on the house ready for winter before the weather turned. The soffit, fascia, corner pieces and entryway columns needed paint, and there was rotten wood in five or six spots. We replaced the rotten wood, did quite a bit of caulking, then put on one coat of Sherwin-Williams Latitude in stock white. The whole job took about 6 hours.

The problem

The homeowner only wanted the trim done. That meant the wood trim around the house, mostly up high: the soffit, the fascia, some corner pieces, the entryway and a few columns.

Once we looked closer, there was a lot of rotten wood. Rot doesn't get better over a Chicago-area winter, so the goal was simple. Fix the bad spots and get fresh paint on the trim before the seasons turned.

What we did, step by step

  1. Replace the rotten wood

    We cut out and replaced about five or six rotten wood spots in the trim. Paint can't save wood that's already soft, so the bad pieces had to go first.

  2. Caulk the trim

    We did quite a bit of caulking along the trim. Sealing the gaps keeps water from getting back behind the wood.

  3. Paint one coat of Latitude

    We put on one coat of Sherwin-Williams Latitude in stock white across the trim, from the roofline down to the entryway columns.

How long it took

The homeowner called hoping to squeeze the job in right before the turn of the seasons. We made it work. The whole job came together in about 6 hours, wood replacement and caulking included.

The tricky part

A few spots had us looking up at the roof, thinking the pitch was a lot steeper than it was. Once we got up there, it was easily walkable. That made the high trim a lot easier to reach.

The result

The homeowner was absolutely ecstatic. The trim is crisp and white again, the rotten wood is gone, and the house is ready for winter. Now the homeowner can't wait for people to walk past the house and notice it.

Project photos: Lake in the Hills, IL

Why this matters in Lake in the Hills

Lake in the Hills is a McHenry County village that grew fast in the 1990s, so a lot of its homes now have trim that's been through 25 or more Illinois winters. Snow, ice and freeze-thaw cycles are hard on wood trim, and the soffit and fascia take the worst of it. Catching rotten spots before winter keeps a small repair from turning into a bigger one. See our painting services in Lake in the Hills.

Common questions from Lake in the Hills homeowners

Why does the wood trim around my roofline rot?

Water gets in. When caulk cracks or paint wears thin, rain and melting snow soak into bare wood, and soffit and fascia sit right where water runs off the roof. Over a few winters, that wood goes soft. On this Lake in the Hills home, we found five or six rotten spots in the trim, mostly up high, and replaced them before painting.

Can I just paint over rotten trim?

No. Paint won't hold soft, rotten wood together, and it traps moisture that keeps the rot going. It just hides the problem for a season. The rotten piece has to be cut out and replaced first. On this Lake in the Hills job, we replaced five or six rotten spots, caulked the trim, and only then painted it.

How long does it take to repair and paint the exterior trim on a house?

It depends on how much rot there is, but this one went fast. On this Lake in the Hills home, replacing five or six rotten wood spots, caulking and putting one coat of Sherwin-Williams Latitude on the soffit, fascia, corner trim and entryway columns took about 6 hours. We got it done right before the seasons turned.

Why caulk exterior trim before painting it?

Caulk seals the gaps where trim boards meet each other and the house, so water can't sneak behind the wood. Paint alone won't bridge those gaps. On this Lake in the Hills home, we did quite a bit of caulking after replacing the rotten wood, then painted the trim in stock white with Sherwin-Williams Latitude.

Do painters have to get on the roof to paint soffit and fascia?

Sometimes. A lot of soffit and fascia can be reached from a ladder, but some spots are easier from the roof itself. On this Lake in the Hills job, the roof looked steeper from the ground than it really was. Once we got up there, it was easily walkable, which made the high trim simpler to reach.

Do you repair and paint exterior trim in Lake in the Hills?

Yes. Pullen Painters repairs and paints exterior trim in Lake in the Hills and across McHenry, Lake and Kane County. That includes soffit, fascia, corner trim, columns and replacing rotten wood before we paint. Visit our Lake in the Hills painting page to see what we do in town, or ask us for a free estimate.

Stop Living With Spaces You Don’t Absolutely Love!

Imagine walking into your home and actually loving what you see. Clean lines, fresh color, and rooms that finally feel finished. With Pullen Painters, that’s exactly what we deliver for homeowners across Hampshire and the surrounding area.

Fill out the form and our team will review your project details, then reach out with clear next steps, a fair estimate, and scheduling options that work around your life.

  • Replace tired, scuffed walls with crisp, professional finishes
  • Choose colors that actually fit your home and lighting
  • Protect your siding, trim, and deck from Illinois weather
  • Increase curb appeal and pride in your home

Tell us a bit about your project today, and let’s get your home looking the way you’ve been picturing it.

Review image
Andrew E.

Amazing customer service and excellent communication from beginning to end. Couldn’t be anymore pleased with the work and pride these guys take in doing the job. 100% Recommend.

Mikel
Mike L.

We had an amazing experience with Pullen Painters their attention to detail, communication, integrity and willingness to go above and beyond to help meet our painting needs. 

Nicole
Nicole D.

The reviews don’t lie. Great company, great quality, great work. So happy with how everything turned out!

Jeff p
Jeffrey P.

A consummate professional who took care of my painting needs better than I could have imagined. This guy was willing to give me the shirt off of his back to make me happy.

Michelle Headshot
Call us at (312) 675-1000 or send a message!

Michelle will respond to you the same business day!

Estimate Form Pullen Painters

We work with your schedule to explore your vision on-site and in person, at no cost to you.