Serving McHenry, Lake & Kane County

EXTERIOR GARAGE REPAINT · MCHENRY, IL

Why Was the Paint Peeling Off This McHenry Garage in Sheets?

The last painter used the wrong paint. Here's how we stripped the failing coat and repainted this one-car garage the right way.

  • McHenry, IL
  • Completed September 2026
Freshly repainted detached one-car garage in McHenry, IL, front view with white siding and garage door

The short answer

The paint on this McHenry, IL garage was peeling off in sheets because a previous painter used the wrong product, most likely interior paint, on exterior wood siding. We pressure washed, let the wood dry a full week, scraped all failing paint, spot primed bare wood with oil-based primer, and finished with two coats of exterior paint.

The problem

The homeowner called us because the paint on their detached one-car garage was coming off in sheets. Not little chips. Whole sheets.

Once we looked at it, the cause was clear. The last painters used the wrong material on the wood siding, most likely an interior paint. Interior paint isn't made to flex with wood that swells in summer and shrinks in winter, and it doesn't hold up to rain and sun. When it loses its grip, it peels in big pieces. Painting over it just traps the problem underneath.

What we did, step by step

  1. Pressure wash the whole garage

    We washed off the dirt, grime and mildew first. New paint won't stick to any of it.

  2. Let the wood dry for a full week

    Wood siding holds water after a wash. We came back a week later so we weren't sealing moisture under fresh paint.

  3. Scrape off all failing paint

    Every loose or lifting spot came off the siding. If it wasn't bonded to the wood, it went.

  4. Sand the edges

    We lightly sanded where old paint met bare wood, so the new coats wouldn't show a ridge.

  5. Spot prime bare wood with oil-based primer

    Oil-based primer soaks into bare wood and gives the topcoat something solid to hold on to.

  6. Apply two coats of exterior paint

    We finished with two full coats of the correct exterior paint.

How long it took

We were out to give an estimate within 48 hours of the call, and the homeowner said yes on the spot. About two weeks later we were back to pressure wash. Then we waited a full week for the siding to dry before any scraping or painting.

That week can feel slow. It's also the step that keeps new paint from failing the same way the old paint did.

The tricky part

Most of the siding cleaned up well, but a few spots needed extra attention. We worked those with caulk or wood filler so gaps and dings wouldn't show through the new paint or let water back into the wood.

The result

The garage now has a solid, fully bonded paint job on the siding, trim and doors, with no peeling left anywhere. The homeowner was thrilled to see the difference.

“That new garage looks amazing.”

Homeowner, McHenry, IL

Project photos: McHenry, IL

Why this matters in McHenry

McHenry sits along the Fox River, with humid summers and hard winters. Exterior wood swells and shrinks through all of it, and that movement is exactly where the wrong paint fails first. If your garage or siding in McHenry is peeling in sheets, find out what was used before anyone paints over it. Here's more about our painting services in McHenry.

Common questions from McHenry homeowners

Why is the paint peeling off my garage in sheets?

When paint comes off in big sheets instead of small flakes, it usually never bonded to the wood in the first place. On this McHenry garage, the last painter used the wrong product, most likely interior paint, on exterior wood siding. Interior paint can't handle the swelling, shrinking, rain and sun that outdoor wood goes through, so it lets go in large pieces.

Can you paint over peeling paint?

No. New paint only holds as well as whatever is under it. If the old coat is loose, the new coat will peel right along with it. We scrape off every loose spot, sand the edges smooth and prime any bare wood before a single topcoat goes on.

How long does it take to fix a peeling garage paint job?

On this McHenry job, we gave an estimate within 48 hours of the call and were back to pressure wash about two weeks later. Then we let the siding dry for a full week before scraping, priming and painting. Don't rush that drying week. Painting over damp wood is one of the ways new paint fails early.

Why use an oil-based primer on bare wood?

Oil-based primer soaks into bare wood and seals it, which gives the exterior topcoat a solid surface to grip. We spot primed every area where the old paint came off, then covered the whole garage with two coats of exterior paint.

Do you paint garages and siding in McHenry and nearby towns?

Yes. Pullen Painters paints garages, siding, trim and doors in McHenry and across McHenry, Lake and Kane County. Visit our McHenry painting page to see the services we offer in town, or request a free estimate.

Stop Living With Spaces You Don’t Absolutely Love!

Imagine walking into your home and actually loving what you see. Clean lines, fresh color, and rooms that finally feel finished. With Pullen Painters, that’s exactly what we deliver for homeowners across Hampshire and the surrounding area.

Fill out the form and our team will review your project details, then reach out with clear next steps, a fair estimate, and scheduling options that work around your life.

  • Replace tired, scuffed walls with crisp, professional finishes
  • Choose colors that actually fit your home and lighting
  • Protect your siding, trim, and deck from Illinois weather
  • Increase curb appeal and pride in your home

Tell us a bit about your project today, and let’s get your home looking the way you’ve been picturing it.

Review image
Andrew E.

Amazing customer service and excellent communication from beginning to end. Couldn’t be anymore pleased with the work and pride these guys take in doing the job. 100% Recommend.

Mikel
Mike L.

We had an amazing experience with Pullen Painters their attention to detail, communication, integrity and willingness to go above and beyond to help meet our painting needs. 

Nicole
Nicole D.

The reviews don’t lie. Great company, great quality, great work. So happy with how everything turned out!

Jeff p
Jeffrey P.

A consummate professional who took care of my painting needs better than I could have imagined. This guy was willing to give me the shirt off of his back to make me happy.

Michelle Headshot
Call us at (312) 675-1000 or send a message!

Michelle will respond to you the same business day!

Estimate Form Pullen Painters

We work with your schedule to explore your vision on-site and in person, at no cost to you.